Narc. Magazine Online
Reliably informed
Simon Lunt discovers a triumphant post-modern release where spiritual malaise, academic absurdity and youthful yearning intertwine
Matador Records
Released: 02.05.25
Without doubt this is Car Seat Headrest’s most ambitious project yet: a rock opera staged at the fictional Parnassus University, where spiritual malaise, academic absurdity and youthful yearning intertwine.
Will Toledo, emerging from a long period of illness and introspection, blends classic rock dramaturgy (think Tommy, Ziggy Stardust) with philosophical weight – all channelled through characters like Beolco and Devereaux, who wrestle with faith, identity and the canon. The glorious 19-minute Planet Desperation is a prog cathedral; Gethsemane is pure existential theatre. Ives’ guitar and analogue sound design lend sonic depth to Toledo’s loftiest of visions.
Post-modern, and defiantly sincere, The Scholars isn’t just an album – it’s more of a thesis. Fans of high-concept narrative rock will find plenty to annotate. Required listening for anyone who ever tried (and failed) to outgrow their coming-of-age.
